skip to Main Content
Doctor Wins Job Back After Being Sacked For Hiring Drunk Obstetrician

Doctor wins job back after being sacked for hiring drunk obstetrician

A doctor has won his job back after being sacked for hiring a drunk obstetrician with a history of alcohol problems.

The Industrial Relations Commission ruled Queensland Health’s dismissal had been “harsh, unjust and unreasonable” and ordered his immediate reinstatement.

Doctor wins job back after hiring drunk obstetrician

Queensland Health employed Doctor Greg Coffey (above left) at the Wide Bay Hospital and Health Service.

He worked as director of medical services earning a $560,000-a-year salary.

However, in September 2017, Queensland Health sacked him over his role in assessing the suitability of Dr Jacobus Cloete.

Dr Cloete had applied for a job at Bundaberg Hospital.

Following the interview, he began working at the hospital in September 2016.

However, two months into the job, a supervisor asked him to take a breath test after noticing a smell of alcohol on his breath.

Cloete subsequently disappeared, never undergoing the test, and never returning to the hospital.

Dr Cloete disappeared after his supervisor asked him to take a breath test.

Special conditions

The Australian Health Practitioner Regulatory Agency had previously imposed conditions on Dr Cloete.

Specifically, that he abstain from alcohol.

Dr Coffey knew about the conditions during the interview with Dr Cloete, however, he failed to tell the other members of the recruiting committee.

He also failed to ask Dr Cloete to commit to regular breath testing as part of his employment conditions.

The Industrial Relations Commission heard evidence that:

“Dr Coffey had formed the view that Dr Cloete’s conditions were consistent with a doctor who had made a good recovery and was well and truly on the path to full remission from an episode of alcohol abuse.”

Termination ‘disproportionate’

Industrial commissioner John Thompson found Dr Coffey’s termination was “disproportionate” to the way he handled Dr Cloete’s recruitment process.

“On consideration of all the evidence and material before the Commission, I have determined that Dr Coffey’s termination was “harsh, unjust and unreasonable and accordingly was unfair dismissal.”

A Wide Bay Hospital and Health Service spokeswoman told The Courier-Mail the department accepted the QIRC’s decision.

Bundaberg Hospital where Doctor Cloete worked until asked to undergo a alcohol breath test. (Picture: Whitsunday Times)

 Please call our specialist team at Fair Work Claims today on

1300 324 748

To connect with us, please follow us on


Fair Work Claims is part of the Supportah Network.

We are a private consultancy and advocacy firm with no affiliation to any government agency, commission or tribunal.

Get in touch with us

    First Name (required)

    Last Name (required)


    Your Email (required)

    Mobile Phone (required)

    Your State

    Client Type (required)

    Matter Type (required)

    Tell us some more about your issue

    Back To Top